AJ Lee & Jay Lethal
A long time before she married CM Punk, AJ Lee had dated ROH and TNA star, Jay Lethal. AJ met Jay in 2007 when she started her wrestling career. Jay helped AJ train and soon enough, the two started dating. After spending a few years together, the couple split up.
Zack Ryder & Tenille Dashwood (Emma)
Back when she was wresting for WWE, Tenille Dashwood was dating Zack Ryder. They started dating in 2005 and were often seen out and about in Florida. The pair split up in 2016, which surprised their fans.